**Student Review** by Gabby Bierlein
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Book reviews written by a high school librarian.
**Student Review** by Gabby Bierlein
Genre: Realistic Fiction
**Student Review by Fielding Montgomery**
Genre: Philosophy
In the book Discourse on the Method by Rene Descartes, Descartes writes about the method through which he claims to have proven the existence of God and make substantial advancements in all fields of study. He describes his process in which he broke down all preexisting thoughts and biases he had and worked on individually reexamining these “truths” to try to discover what is really the truth. He does this by sitting alone for long periods of time and conversing with his mind. He lays out a lot of ground rules as to how you should act while using this method to develop your mind, comparing it a house. He also mentions how this is something you can only do for yourself, you can’t force others to change their thoughts. He first applies his method to algebra and geometry and has great success. He later comes to the conclusion that the only thing he can truly prove is that “I’m thinking, therefore I exist.” Because of this truth, he then decides that his mind must be separate from his body, helping him to prove the existence of God. He does this by arguing that a perfect God cannot be imagined by an imperfect mind and through geometry. He then goes on to discuss how he was going to put his work into a book but didn’t want to have controversy like Galileo did so he breaks it into essays.
This book is a very interesting read if you’re into philosophy. It brings up interesting reasoning on many human things as well as the existence of God. The quote “I’m thinking, therefore I exist,” is a very famous quote and very deep. Decartes’s discussions with his mind provide a new way of thinking. This book has a large vocabulary and is at times confusing to read. Those who are not truly interested in philosophy will not appreciate this book. Also, Descartes comes off as very arrogant in how he talks of himself, this could turn some away from the book. Even through all this the philosophy and thinking is thought provoking. This is definitely a suggested, short read.
-Fielding Montgomery
Genre: Realistic Fiction
# of Pages: 325
RAC Book: No
Jem has always seen numbers when she looks directly into people’s eyes, but she never knew what they meant. When her mother overdoses and dies, Jem realizes that the numbers she sees spell out the day a person will die. Naturally, Jem tries not to get close to anyone or look directly into their eyes because she cannot bear knowing such important information. A boy named Spider tries to befriend her anyway, and Jem finds herself wanting to spend time with him, even though she knows his death day is mere weeks away. Can she change his fate?
This story has an interesting premise, but drags in places and many readers will struggle to get through it. The ending is fast paced and interesting, but the journey to get there may lose some readers along the way. Jem’s character seems flat and uninteresting until the end when she accepts her role in life. This was a clever idea, but only somewhat realized through the story.
Genre: Realistic Fiction
# of Pages: 287 p.
RAC Book: Yes
Katarina Bishop is the daughter of a notorious thief, but has decided to get out of the business in order to go to a prestigious boarding school. When she is kicked out of the school for a crime she did not commit, she finds out that a powerful man has decided to target her father as the culprit for some paintings of his that were stolen. If she is not able to find and return the missing paintings to him then he will hurt her father. One way or another she finds herself back in the world of heists and cons.
For those who loved the Gallagher Girls books this will be another winner. The characters are fun, the plot twists and turns, and there is room for a sequel. Recommended for those who enjoy heist books or are simply looking for a fun summer read.
Click on the following link in order to view my video on books that include themes on bullying. Some of the bullying is by other students, some is by parents, and some is even by the government.

Genre: Historical fiction
Age Level: 14 and up
# of Pages: 211 p.
RAC Book: Yes
Moshe is a Jewish boy living in Poland with his family in 1918 when the story begins. He has very weak legs and even when they grow strong enough to stand they are crooked. Due to the brutal bullying endured by Jewish boys during this time he must learn how to fight in order to defend himself since he cannot run away. When his family relocates to Paris and circumstances begin to get better for them he begins boxing in matches for fun. He marries and has a child, but then Germany invades France and he is sent to a concentration camp. He must use his skills as a fighter in order to survive.
This Holocaust story has the unusual twist that the main character is a boxer and because of that survives many difficult situations. It is based on a real man’s story that the author met, but some of the specific conversations are fictionalized. Life in the concentration camp is described from many aspects as Moshe moves through many jobs and sees a lot of what is going on. There are many graphic and violent incidents in the camp, so students reading this should have a basic understanding of the Holocaust before reading it. It is a translated story so it doesn’t flow as well as some stories, but it is still easy to understand and accurately depicts the story this author felt needed to be told. A good Holocaust story.

Genre: Realistic Fiction
Age Level: 14 and up
# of Pages: 316 p.
RAC Book: Yes
In this sequel to The Battle of Jericho November Nelson is dealing with the death of her boyfriend after a hazing ritual went bad. To make matters worse, she discovers that she is pregnant. She was planning to spend the summer in an Ivy League summer program which would hopefully lead to a very productive senior year. When she tells her mother about her pregnancy she is understandably upset. November faces a lot of difficult decisions as she endures this pregnancy.
Meanwhile, Jericho, the cousin of the boy who died, is having an equally difficult time coping with his friend’s untimely death. He decides to try football in order to have something new to do instead of the band, which he previously loved but now feels is a painful reminder of his cousin. He tries to help November in any way he can, but is struggling with his own emotions as well.
This was a good story about teenage pregnancy and death, but addresses similar concepts to The First Part Last. The characters were complicated and interesting and were the strength of the story. Nothing these characters were dealing with was easy and was not portrayed that way. The ending took an unexpected turn, but was a little predictable nonetheless. Most readers will guess what November’s decision will be, but will enjoy it anyway.

Genre: Realistic Fiction
Age Level: 12 and up
# of Pages: 208 p.
RAC Book: Yes
2008 Iowa Teen Award Winner
Brady loves living so close to the Chesapeake Bay. His father is a crab and oyster fisherman and he has two best friends, Digger and J.T. One day Brady sees the neighbor’s red kayak out before the boys go to school. He debates whether to yell and tell them it’s too dangerous to be out, but his friends convince him they will be fine. Brady is pulled out of school by his father later that morning because the kayak never returned and it contained the neighbor and her son. Brady had babysat for Ben and wanted to help find him.
As the search and rescue teams start heading off down the river Brady learns that the woman was found but was in shock. By chance he finds Ben and tries to resuscitate him while driving the boat back to the ambulance. By the time he gets there they have a pulse and Brady is hailed as a hero for the rest of the day. Things begin to go terribly wrong, however, when he starts to suspect that the kayak sinking was no accident and wonders how he should proceed.
This book was captivating in the way the story was revealed and in how it was explained. Brady faces one difficult decision after another and must decide who he should protect and who he should hurt. His father helps him decide that finding the right decision is easy, it’s just hard to act on it. This book will be a hit with teen boys due to its short and to the point nature, as well as for its interesting content. It would be good for classroom discussions on responsibility and making choices that will affect the rest of your life and many other people’s lives as well.

Genre: Suspense, Realistic Fiction
Age Level: 14 and up
# of pages: 310 p.
RAC Book: Yes
The story begins when Alice who has just left her two week old baby for the first time ventures out for two hours and comes home to find she does not know the baby in the crib. She believes that someone has come into her mother-in-law’s house, where her and her husband live, and snatched her baby only to replace it with another newborn. Her husband becomes angry with her as she refuses to accept that this is her baby and insists on calling the police. The police have a difficult time deciding how to proceed since no babies have been reported missing and there is a baby present at the house.
The story alternates between Alice and one of the police detectives. He is generally accepted to be a really good detective and feels that this case is not as innocent as it first appears. He does not know if he believes Alice about someone switching the babies, but believes something is amiss. His colleagues all believe Alice is crazy and suffering from depression and psychosis from her difficult delivery.
The mystery was intriguing all the way up until everything is explained. The resolution is not as good as one would hope after such an intriguing mystery has been set up. There are moments where Alice’s husband shows tortuous feelings toward her for casting doubt on their family. It is never fully explained why she allows him to do this to her. The ending is satisfying, but unbelievable. The details provided weave together to form a good pace and some surprises as details are revealed, but again the motivations of the characters in their actions is not always fully explained. Readers who enjoy mystery and suspense will enjoy this, but anyone who has difficulty with people undergoing very degrading and difficult situations will find it troubling.

Genre: Realistic Fiction/Multicultural Fiction
Age Level: 14 and up
# of pages: 200
RAC Book: Yes
Emily Goldberg has been called to Puerto Rico for her grandmother’s funeral. She has never met her grandmother or anyone else on her mother’s side of the family. Her mother came to the U.S. to go to college, became a professor, married Emily’s father, and never went home. Once they get to the funeral, her mother has a difficult time dealing with her estrangment from her family and asks Emily if she will stay with her in Puerto Rico for the summer, while Emily’s dad and brother go home. Even though she was supposed to go on a road trip with her friends, Emily can’t refuse her mother in this time of need and chooses to stay.
She finds that not everyone in the family is happy to see them and she learns more about her mother’s estrangement from her family. Family, knowledge, tradition, and communication are all themes in this story as a family tries to come together after the death of a matriarch. Emily learns a lot about her heritage and the strength of her mother to fight for what she believes in.

Genre: Historical Fiction/WW II Germany
Reading Level: Age 14 and up
# of Pages: 550
RAC book: Yes
This story, narrated by Death, follows Liesel, a young girl during WWII in Germany who is sent by her mother to live with foster parents. Her brother was supposed to go too, but died on the journey. Liesel feels abandoned, but soon learns to love her new father. He is kind and sits with her when she has nightmares. He also plays the accordian for her. Her new mother is harsh and uses poor language, but as time goes on Liesel comes to appreciate that times are hard and her new mother does indeed care about her.
The story follows many different aspects of this time including Hitler Youth, concentration camps, rations, Kristallnacht, and the pressure to join the Nazi party. Liesel’s family hides Max, a Jew, for awhile as a favor to a friend of her foster father’s who died in WWI. When her father makes the mistake of showing compassion for Jews who are marched through town from a concentration camp he is punished by getting drafted into the war. When her best friend, Rudy, is summoned to serve in the war, his father refuses and he is drafted as well. Liesel tries her best to follow the rules, but she becomes bitter at what the party has done to her friends, family, and herself. She begins to steal books so that she can learn new ideas different from those fed to her in Hitler Youth. Her books help her survive many difficult times that lay ahead for her.
The Book Thief is a wonderful story about a girl trying to survive Nazi Germany. She never fully recovers from losing her mother and her brother, but nevertheless finds some happiness through her foster parents, best friend Rudy, new friend Max, and finally through her books. The idea of knowledge and power are strong themes in this book and reflect how Hitler stripped his people of these in order to take control. This story is powerful and will stay with a reader long after he or she has finished it.

Genre: Fantasy
Age Level: 14 and up
# of pages: 302
RAC Book: Yes
Schuyler comes from a well distinguished family, but they have lost their family wealth over time. She does not feel the need to fit in at school and seems content to go through life as an outcast. Bliss, on the other hand, is a new girl from Texas who has been given the opportunity to hang out with Mimi Force, one of the popular Force twins. She belongs to the popular crowd of thin, beautiful, and rich young people. When she meets a boy she likes she wonders if she can give up her popularity to be with him. Both of these girls come to learn that they are Blue Bloods.
In this book, the Blue Bloods are vampires and the Red Bloods are humans. Most people are not told they are a vampire until they are teenagers. All of those beautiful, rich, thin people are vampires and as such cannot be killed…or so they thought. When a classmate is murdered and all of her blood is drained, some of the teens begin to wonder if someone is out there killing vampires.
Vampire books are popular with my students right now. This one was not as good as the series by Stephenie Meyer, but it was entertaining. Each vampire book has a different set of rules for explaining their existence and this book is no exception. Some of the details given about vampires in this story are interesting and thought provoking. The characters do not have as much depth as the Meyers series, but for those students who like to read about the wealthy and powerful this will be a hit.
Genre: Poetry and Historical Fiction
Age Level: Age 14 and up
# of pages: 88
RAC Book: No
The Braid is set in Scotland during the 1850s. During this time, landowners in Scotland found out they could make more money by using their land for grazing than for renting it out. Many families were told to evacuate overnight. In this story, Sarah and Jeannie are the oldest two children in a family told to evacuate. On their last night together, Sarah braided some of their hair together so that they will each have a piece when they start their separate journeys. Jeannie evacuates with the family and Sarah stays with her grandmother. The braid they each carry binds them through their difficult times ahead. The story alternates between sisters and integrates the use of poetry. Even though they are separated they will still influence each other’s lives over the years due to their connection with the braid of hair.
This story accurately portrayed the hardships of the times through its depiction of evacuation, sea travel, sickness, unwed mothers, and homeless families. Through it all there is always a ray of hope as the two girls remain optimistic and strive to reach outside their comfort zones in order to stand up for what they feel is right. Despite the hardships both girls endure, they never stop hoping that things will work out for themselves and their sister.