Genre: Realistic Fiction
RAC Book: Yes
2014-2015 Iowa High School Award Winner
Every year a list is posted the Monday before Homecoming listing the four prettiest and four ugliest girls, one for each grade respectively. Each chapter follows one of the eight girls and how they cope with the existence of this list. Danielle, the ugliest freshmen, must deal with the fallout of how her boyfriend handles the news that she was voted on this list. Meanwhile, Abby, the prettiest freshmen faces possibly not being allowed to go to the dance at all due to grades. The “ugliest” sophomore is actually a cute, but very mean girl who is deemed “ugliest” on the inside. The “prettiest” sophomore girl is a girl who has been home-schooled for her entire life and is trying to find independence from her mom with great difficulty. The prettiest junior, Bridget, feels pressured into an eating disorder in order to maintain her image while the ugliest junior reacts quite strongly and refuses to shower or change her clothes for the entire week after the list comes out. The ugliest senior is the first ever to earn that particular honor for all four years of high school and she pretends she is totally fine with it. The prettiest senior feels the pressure to follow in her sister’s footsteps who was the prettiest senior the year before and seemed to fall apart afterward. Each chapter follows a different girl as she navigates through this very difficult week.
This book has earned many awards for good reason. This book delves into many serious issues for high school girls including insecurity, the fear of being excluded, worrying about what others think, eating disorders, dating problems, academic trouble, lying, and problems at home. No one on the list finds happiness no matter which side of the list she is on. While the circumstances around the list may seem unbelievable, the issues surrounding it are completely believable and exist at every high school. A great book to recommend to high school girls, especially ones who are having trouble adjusting.